Thomas Julian Butler

Tom’s Profile

Tom is a Shareholder in Maynard Cooper’s Litigation Practice with a wide-range of trial experience that has led him to handle cases in state and federal courts in more than 15 states across the country, as well as in the Fourth, Fifth and Eleventh Circuit Courts of Appeal. His diverse practice includes class actions, life insurance and annuity sales practice litigation, mass tort, bad faith, ERISA, securities, product liability, general business litigation, and landlord/tenant disputes.

With significant experience representing some of the largest life and retirement companies in the United States in claims, interpleaders, sales practices, rescission, bad faith and punitive damages matters, Tom has earned recognition by Best Lawyers® in the area of Insurance Law. He also devotes a substantial amount of his practice to defending all aspects of consumer class actions, serving as a co-lead counsel in various nationwide settlements. Tom has served as trial counsel in numerous venues, including California, Illinois, Mississippi and Alabama.

Tom’s reputation and skills as a lawyer are widely recognized. In addition to his consistent inclusion in The Best Lawyers in America© for Insurance Law, he was one of the youngest lawyers named to Alabama Super Lawyers for his success in defending class action/mass tort litigation. He serves as an Adjunct Professor of Trial Advocacy at the University of Alabama School of Law.

Tom’s Experience

  • Obtained dismissal of purported statewide class action against property and casualty insurer alleging claim for breach of contract for depreciating labor costs when calculating the actual cash value of the insurance policy. Ware v. Metropolitan Property and casualty Insurance Company, __F. Supp. 3d__, 2016 WL 7209816 (M.D. Ala. Dec. 7, 2016).
  • Trigg v. USAA Casualty Insurance Company No. 2:16-CV05206-R-AS (C.D. Cal. Oct. 3, 2016) (granting motion to dismiss in California statewide class action based upon alleged inconsistencies between policy and California’s insurance regulation requiring that repairs achieve a “reasonable uniform appearance” within the damaged area).
  • Kraetsch v. USAA, 4:14-CV-264-CEJ, (E.D. Mo. March 30, 2015) (granting USAA’S motion to strike plaintiffs’ class action claims before commencement of discovery upon finding that the question of how an insurance policy provision is to be interpreted cannot predominate over the multitude of individual inquiries involved in determining a policyholde’s claim).
  • Lewis v. Principal Financial Group, Inc., 1:14-CV-1779-KAM-JO (E.D.N.Y. March 31, 2015) aff’d 2016 WL 944358 (2nd Cir., March 14, 2016) (after procuring a transfer of case from the District of Nevada to Eastern District of New York, trial court granted defendants’ motion to dismiss in purported nationwide class action alleging breach of contract, breach of trust, breach fiduciary duty, negligence, fraudulent misrepresentation and negligent misrepresentation claims).
  • Saunders v. USAA Life Insurance Co., 2014 WL 5339205 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 17, 2014) (granting defendant’s motion to transfer venue from Northern District of California to Western District of Texas – USAA Life’s headquarters – despite the fact that plaintiffs were California residents and complaint alleged California statutory claims).
  • Bliss & Glennon, Inc. v. Ashley, 420 S.W. 3d 379 (Tex. App. – Hous. (1 Dist.), Jan. 7, 2014) (reversing trial court’s order certifying a nationwide class action in data breach case against insurance brokerage agency) [our law firm was first engaged after the trial court’s class certification order was entered and appeal notice was filed].
  • District Court granted defendant’s motion to strike plaintiff’s nationwide class action allegations and rejected plaintiff’s attempts to aggressively pursue far-reaching and incredibly expensive discovery from defendant and numerous third-parties. Lawson v. Life of the South Insurance Company, 286 F.R.D. 689 (M.D. Ga. Sept. 28, 2012).
  • Allen v. American General Life and Accident Ins. Co. (United States District Court, Northern District of Georgia) – Served as co-lead counsel in successful removal and defense of purported nationwide class action arising from alleged practices associated with lapsing of whole life insurance policies.
  • Burkhalter Transport v. AIG Aviation (United States District Court, Northern District of Mississippi) – Served as co-lead counsel in defense of nationwide class action case arising from cancellation of war-risk coverage rider after events of September 11, 2001. We obtained summary judgment on all claims prior to the plaintiff filing a motion for class certification.
  • McMorris, et al. v. Western-Southern Life Ins. Co. (United States District Court, Southern District of Mississippi) – Served as co-lead counsel in successful removal and defense of multi-plaintiff lawsuit arising from sales practices associated with whole life and universal life insurance policies. We ultimately obtained summary judgment on all claims brought by all plaintiffs.
  • Underwood v. American General Life and Accident Ins. Co., 886 So.2d 807 (Ala. 2004) – Assisted in defense and successful appeal of case filed in Barbour County, Alabama arising from alleged discriminatory pricing of industrial life insurance policies. On appeal, the Alabama Supreme Court determined the common law rule of repose barred all actions that had not been commenced within twenty years from the time they could have been brought.
  • Walden, et al. v. American General Life and Accident Ins. Co., 244 F.Supp.2d 689 (S.D. Miss. 2003) and Booker, et al. v. American General Life and Accident Ins. Co., 257 F.Supp.2d 850 (S.D. Miss. 2003) – Served as lead counsel in developing successful removal and jurisdictional discovery strategy in multi-plaintiff life insurance sales practice cases originally filed in Holmes County, Mississippi. The cases settled on favorable terms to the defendant after defeating plaintiffs’ motion to remand.
  • Bankston v. Hartford Life and Annuity Ins. Co. (Circuit Court of Baldwin County, Alabama) – In addition to conducting vigorous discovery, drafted and successfully argued motion for summary judgment in fraudulent misrepresentation action arising from sale of variable life insurance policy.
  • Monaghan v. American General Life and Accident Ins. Co. (United States District Court, Northern District of Mississippi) – Served as lead counsel in successful removal, defense and appeal of fraud lawsuit arising from sale and lapse of universal life insurance policy.

Tom’s Awards

  • The Best Lawyers in America© for Insurance Law (2013-present)
  • Mid-South Super Lawyers for Class Action (2016-present)
  • Alabama Super Lawyers for Class Action/Mass Torts, Consumer Law (2009-2015)

Tom’s Affiliations & Civic Involvement


  • American Bar Association
  • Alabama State Bar
  • Birmingham Bar Association

Civic Involvement

  • Birmingham Chamber of Commerce Project Corporate Leadership, Class of 2005
  • Mountain Brook Athletic League, Youth Coach
T 205.254.1063
F 205.714.6425
C 205.413.2053
Sarah Campbell
State Bar:Alabama, Mississippi
U.S. Court of Appeals:Fifth Circuit, Eleventh Circuit
University of Alabama School of Law (1999, J.D., magna cum laude; Order of the Coif; Alabama Law Review, Special Works Editor)
Birmingham-Southern College (1995, B.A.)

Honorable Edwin Nelson
United States District Court, Nothern District of Alabama

The recently released edition of the U.S. News-Best Lawyers® “Best Law Firms” positions Maynard Cooper in the National Tier Rankings in 10 areas of practice, including Commercial Litigation, Corporate Law, Land Use & Zoning Law, L...
Birmingham, AL. Maynard Cooper & Gale is pleased to announce that 116 of the Firm’s attorneys have been recognized as leaders in their areas of practice in the 2019 edition of The Best Lawyers in America©. Included in...
Maynard Cooper & Gale is pleased to announce that 95 attorneys have been selected as 2017 Super Lawyers, including 90 among the firm’s Alabama office locations, two in the firm’s New York office, and three in its San Francisco office....
Association of Fraternal Benefit Counsel 2018 Annual Meeting: Tom speaking on "The Rules of the Road": How to Defend High Stakes Litigation
CEFLI Unclaimed Property Summit Meeting IV